Democrats are saying that the vote to pull out was not “John Murtha’s bill”. But when you look at the text it is not very different.
Now that I’ve already covered how John Murtha calls for troops to leave whenever the fight is hard. It’s time to look at his latest rants and those of Democrats who claim that the bill the US House of Representatives voted on last Friday night, H RES 571 is not the same as the bill proposed by John Murtha H. J. RES. 73.
Here is the text of H RES 571:
|
Simple enough, and that was voted down 403 to 3.
Here is what John Murtha proposed. I am putting the real “action words” in bold, because much of it is just B-S Democratic rhetoric!
|
So his bill says “earliest practicable date” and what was voted down Friday gave a date, “immediately”! Given Murtha feels no more can be done, there could be no more practicable date than right now, using his logic! I don’t see much difference there. His bill called for a “quick-reaction U.S. force and an over-the-horizon presence of U.S. Marines”. So if the troops were pulled out there would still be troops “over-the-horizon” in other areas. A “quick-reaction” force could have been proposed in a follow-up bill, but let’s be honest here. A “quick-reaction” force would not be able to do much! So the call for such a force at this point is a bit of a waste and foolish! It would not prove effective! His bill mentions that more troops are needed, so how can he contradict himself in calling for a “quick-reaction” force, as if that would be effective?!!! So better to not have that. Still the bill they voted on Friday is not much different from Murtha’s bill, considering section 2 of his bill was a waste anyway! And section 3 of his bill “diplomacy” could continue if all the troops were pulled. So in total I see the bill that they voted on last Friday as a functional equivalent of John Murtha’s bill! But the Democrats for the most part ran from it, because they realized that they were being held to account for their rhetoric!
Murtha’s bill had 13 co-sponsors:
|
None of them voted for H RES 571!
This just proves that when it was time to put their votes where their big mouths were they shut up real quick!
Troops we love, support and want you to complete the mission! Ignore the nuts that talk smack. As you can see from the vote, they are just playing politics!
Independent Conservative - Copyright 2008 - Copyright Notice
[powered by WordPress.]
38 queries. 0.261 seconds
November 23rd, 2005 at 11:02 am
John Murtha’s sudden jump into the media spotlight might be a clever cover!
Pennsylvania Democratic Congressman John Murtha has some “interesting” connections with companies he is granting government contracts to!
…