Rekjalhew

November 1, 2005

The Bird Flu Pork-Ball!

by @ 12:50 pm. Filed under Questionable Items

Our President is using his “throw money at it” strategy to prepare for a disease that does not exist. A strain of the bird flu that can pass quickly between humans. So far his proposed money tossing would cost American taxpayers over $7 billion, although some headlines only mention $1.2 billion, while revealing the current total costs in the details.

Bush asks Congress for $1.2 billion for bird-flu vaccine

President Bush, warning that the United States is at risk in a possible worldwide flu outbreak, said today he is asking Congress for $1.2 billion for enough vaccine to protect 20 million Americans against the current strain of bird flu.

The president also said the United States must approve liability protection for the makers of lifesaving vaccines.

Bush outlined a strategy that would cost $7.1 billion including:

  • $1.2 billion for the government to buy enough doses of the vaccine against the current strain of bird flu to protect 20 million Americans;
  • $1 billion to stockpile more anti-viral drugs that lessen the severity of the flu symptoms;
  • $2.8 billion to speed the development of vaccines as new strains emerge, a process that now takes months;
  • $583 million for states and local governments to prepare emergency plans to respond to an outbreak.

Bird Flu Facts:

CDC: Key Facts About Avian Influenza (Bird Flu) and Avian Influenza A (H5N1) Virus

Do bird flu viruses infect humans?
Bird flu viruses do not usually infect humans, but several cases of human infection with bird flu viruses have occurred since 1997.

How is bird flu in humans treated?
Studies done in laboratories suggest that the prescription medicines approved for human flu viruses should work in preventing bird flu infection in humans. However, flu viruses can become resistant to these drugs, so these medications may not always work. Additional studies are needed to prove the effectiveness of these medicines.

What is the risk to humans from bird flu?
The risk from bird flu is generally low to most people because the viruses occur mainly among birds and do not usually infect humans. However, during an outbreak of bird flu among poultry (domesticated chicken, ducks, turkeys), there is a possible risk to people who have contact with infected birds or surfaces that have been contaminated with excretions from infected birds. The current outbreak of avian influenza A (H5N1) among poultry in Asia and Europe (see below) is an example of a bird flu outbreak that has caused human infections and deaths. In such situations, people should avoid contact with infected birds or contaminated surfaces, and should be careful when handling and cooking poultry.

What is an avian influenza A (H5N1) virus?
Influenza A (H5N1) virus – also called “H5N1 virus” – is an influenza A virus subtype that occurs mainly in birds. Like all bird flu viruses, H5N1 virus circulates among birds worldwide, is very contagious among birds, and can be deadly.

How is infection with H5N1 virus in humans treated?
The H5N1 virus currently infecting birds in Asia that has caused human illness and death is resistant to amantadine and rimantadine, two antiviral medications commonly used for influenza. Two other antiviral medications, oseltamavir and zanamavir, would probably work to treat flu caused by the H5N1 virus, but additional studies still need to be done to prove their effectiveness.

What is the risk to people in the United States from the H5N1 bird flu outbreak in Asia and Europe ?
The current risk to Americans from the H5N1 bird flu outbreak in Asia is low. The strain of H5N1 virus found in Asia and Europe has not been found in the United States . There have been no human cases of H5N1 flu in the United States . It is possible that travelers returning from affected countries in Asia could be infected if they were exposed to the virus. Since February 2004, medical and public health personnel have been watching closely to find any such cases.

The worst influenza pandemic

CDC: Information About Influenza Pandemics

1918-19, “Spanish flu,” [A (H1N1)], caused the highest number of known influenza deaths. (However, the actual influenza virus subtype was not detected in the 1918-19 pandemic). More than 500,000 people died in the United States , and up to 50 million people may have died worldwide. Many people died within the first few days after infection, and others died of secondary complications. Nearly half of those who died were young, healthy adults. Influenza A (H1N1) viruses still circulate today after being introduced again into the human population in 1977.

CDC Avian Influenza Infection in Humans
CDC: General Information on Avian Influenza

(Edit 11/6/2005, the prior source that was posted here for Bird Flu Facts has been removed and CDC information put in instead. This was done because the prior source used did not like being quoted here and also that information did not provide a source for the statements made. The CDC is a much more reliable and trustworthy source.)

A map of areas already affected by the Bird Flu. Hat tip to normblog for the link to the map.

Do we know that the bird flu will mutate into something that spreads quickly between humans? No. We just think it “might” happen! Now lets give Mr. Moneybags (Bush) the benefit of the doubt and say the bird flu will mutate into something that spreads quickly between humans. Do we know that the $1.2 billion spent on a vaccine against a current strain that a few bird workers have caught (which does not currently spread between humans) would work on that mutated strain? No. So he wants to spend $2.8 billion to prepare for other strains. Given there is no current mutated strain and we don’t know that anything we make right now will work on something that does not yet exist, I must say the $1.2 billion is a big gamble! A gamble I don’t think we can afford. I say not with my money President Bush! In fact, I don’t feel we should spend $1 billion to stockpile anti-viral drugs when nobody has found a strain that spreads quickly between humans yet! I also don’t see the immediate need to spend $583 million for states to prepare for something that does not exist! And $2.8 billion to speed the development of vaccines against new strains of something that does not exist is also a gamble that might prove to be a waste.

I would be more comfortable with a much smaller amount of money spent on continued research. But with no actual strain spreading quickly between humans anywhere in the world I don’t like this large amount of money being spent. If we saw a mutated strain in any of the currently affected areas, this expense would be far more justifiable. But currently no! We do not even have proof of any birds in the USA even being affected by this yet!

I think this is honestly a Presidential diversion program. And I would prefer that President Bush stop trying to divert attention from other important issues by using a form of flu that does not yet exist! I think everyone who agrees should contact their representatives to say “not on my dime, address real existing problems now and new problems when they exist somewhere in the world”.

In all this, the real effort might be to create legislation that protects drug companies from liability when they develop vaccines. I think offering drug companies protection for vaccines they develop is a great idea! But I do not feel we need an over $7 billion dollar pork project just to make that happen!

Also if administered, everyone having a vaccine would result in Americans having less natural resistance to the bird flu. But just the same if a fast spreading human form existed I would say the expense was justifiable. For now I feel America should continue working to isolate potential outbreaks in birds, plus some other smaller research and that is all!

We’ve got real issues like terrorism and illegal immigration to deal with. We’ve got more Americans catching things from people who enter the USA illegally than people who have caught bird flu strain H5N1!

So Mr. President, how about saving some of my money for a change? And if you must spend it, please spend it on something that exist!



4 Responses to “The Bird Flu Pork-Ball!”

  1. Another Stupid News Blog Says:

    The Balance of Lives

    Sources: ABC News: Bush to Announce Strategy to Battle Flu; Washington Post: Gates Foundation Pledges More Toward Malaria Research
    George Bush is ready to spend $7.5 billion dollars to protect the US from a disease that currently poses no danger and …

  2. Independent Conservative Says:

    The Bird Flu Pork-Ball, Part II

    The more I hear about America’s over $7 Billion Bird Flu preparations, the more I feel we are engaging in an unwise gamble with taxpayer dollars.

  3. Independent Conservative Says:

    The world is waking up to the Bird Flu Pork Ball!

    As I’ve been saying for some time now, this whole Bird Flu matter has been way overblown. AND OVER SPENT! See my related posts for details if you did not catch them earlier.

  4. TJs Blog of Unknown Kadath » The Balance of Lives Says:

    [...] Independent Conservative [...]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Independent Conservative - Copyright 2008 - Copyright Notice

[powered by WordPress.]

32 queries. 0.365 seconds